Geraci’s Slice Shop Menu
Welcome to Geraci’s Slice Shop, where authentic Italian flavors meet a casual dining experience in the heart of Cleveland. This unclaimed gem specializes in an array of delectable pizzas, catering to every palate with options ranging from classic cheese to innovative vegan choices.
- The OG Cheese: A must-try for traditionalists, featuring rich red sauce and fresh mozzarella.
- The Pep: Boasting thick-cut pepperoni that elevates the taste to new heights.
- Spicy Vegan: Perfect for plant-based lovers, this pie is a flavor explosion with vegan mozzarella and herbs.
- The Pink Hawaiian: A sweet and savory delight with a BBQ drizzle, combining bacon, ham, and pineapple.
Add to that their enticing combo deals, and you’ve got a menu that prompts repeated visits. Geraci’s Slice Shop is perfect for a cozy meal, takeout, or delivery. Every dish bursts with genuine flavors, making it a true slice of pizza paradise.
Legends (Whole Pies)
The OG Cheese
Classic cheese pizza. Red sauce, fresh mozzarella.
The Pep
Red sauce, fresh mozzarella, thick cut pepperoni.
A Spicy Vegan
Red sauce, vegan mozz, vegan pep, banana peppers, herbs, and crushed red pepper.
The Pink Hawaiian
Pink sauce, mozz, bacon, ham, pineapple. Finished with a BBQ drizzle.
Hot Tito
Red sauce, mozz, thick cut pep, sausage, romano, hot honey drizzle.
Bianco
Fresh garlic, olive oil, parsley, romano, mozz, and ricotta cheese.
Grandma G's (1/2 Sheet - 12 cut)
Square pie with garlic, olive oil, romano, mozzarella and stripes of red, pink, and pesto sauces, finished with grandma's secret spice mix.
Sicilian Square (1/2 Sheet - 12 cut)
Square pie, with red sauce, herbs, romano, and olive oil.
Retro Roma Supreme
Dill Time
12' Pep Heart Pizza and Cannolli Combo
XL Round (18" - 12 cut)
XL Home Plate Pie (18" - 12 cut)
Half Sheet (18" - 12 cut)
Gluten Free (12" - 6 cuts)
BYO Pizza (Whole Pies)
Other 'Not Pizzas'
Personal Pan Lasagna
Our Diners, Drive Ins, and Dives certified Personal Pan Lasagna will leave you speechless. Layers of fresh lasagna noodles, meatball mix, ricotta mix and melted mozzarella cheese. Finished with a sprinkle of fresh romano.
Mama's Meatball
3 classic meatballs in Geraci's Red Sauce. Featured on Diners, Drive Ins, and Dives.
Mama's Meatball Flight
Try all 3 sauces over top of our famous meatballs. Pink, Red, and Pesto. The perfect appetizer!
Mama's Baked Meatball Hero
Fresh seeded Italian sub bun, famous meatballs, red sauce, melted provolone and a sprinkle of fresh romano cheese.
Gabadrool
Fresh seeded Italian sub bun, sliced capicola, salami, ham, and provolone. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pepper mix, finished with our house Italian dressing.
Garlic Pillows
Everyone's favorite! Our garlic pillows are light, airy, and baked to perfection. finished with house made garlic butter and loads of romano cheese. Choose the perfect dunk and have at it!
Buffalo Pillows
Our famous garlic pillows with a twist. Tossed in house buffalo pesto sauce and melted bleu cheese. We recommend dunking these in ranch.
Dunk Sauce
Spice up your pizza slice with one of our signature dipping sauces. AKA "Dunks".
Chips
Bag of chips to compliment any item on our menu.
Caesar Marie
Mixed greens, croutons, shaved parmesan, fresh grated romano, and caesar dressing.
Big Gus
Mixed greens, fresh sliced Italian deli meats, pepperoncini pepper, tomato, lemon wedge, black olives, mozzarella cheese & Italian vinaigrette dressing.
Geraci's House
Mixed greens, carrot and cabbage garnish, cherry tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella.
Caprese
Mixed greens bed of lettuce, fresh sliced tomatoes, fresh sliced mozzarella, balsamic drizzle, olive oil, and salt & pepper.
Small House Salad
Large House Salad
Salads
Desserts
Tiramisu
Ice Pops
1 Slice Combo - Online
2 Slice Combo - Online
Garlic Pillow 5ct (11am-3pm M-F ONLY)
Need Ranch
Combos
The Skipper Combo
The Skipper Combo
One XL (18" - 12 cuts) single-topping pizza, one large house salad, 10 count pillows + 1 dunk.
The Goat Combo
Two XL (18" - 12 cuts) single-topping pizzas, two large house salads, 20 count pillows + dunks.
